Tags
Nearly four weeks ago, Canadians elected a new Prime Minister. Citizens came out in droves to polling stations all across the country – so many, in fact, that at least one polling station in Alberta ran out of ballots. But what often went unmentioned, except by those who experienced it firsthand, is an inconsistent process for voters with disabilities or mobility challenges. For those with disabilities, who face discrimination and incomprehension on a regular basis, an overwhelming sentiment was felt that on October 19- a day when all Canadians were to be treated equally by casting their ballot – inequality still very much exists.
A Human Rights complaint was filed after a 2011 Federal election, after a voter who used a walker for mobility was forced to enter a polling station by going down a flight of stairs on his behind. A short time later, that same polling station was still in use, with the same barriers to access with walker or wheelchair. The Canadian government implemented changes for voters with disabilities, theoretically upholding the dignity of all Canadians. Four years later, progress had been made, but – as you will soon see – we still have a long way to go. Even though Elections Canada has made policies to accommodate voters with disabilities, many of these require advanced notice – whether it’s booking an ASL interpreter (if you are not able to bring one yourself) or having an Elections Canada volunteer come to your home so you can cast your ballot prior to Election Day. For Election day itself, independently accessing a voting booth is far from a simple or consistent process. From polling stations lacking clear signage for easy visibility, to inoperable or non-existent elevators, to volunteers not knowing about options for voters with visual impairments, it’s clear that voting is not as smooth for everyone as it could be.
I chose not to vote in this election, for a variety of personal and political reasons. But based on what several visually impaired friends have told me, the process was far from smooth or consistent. At best, one friend was guided from the front door, to filling out paperwork, to casting his ballot, and back out again. Some polling stations had large print lists of candidates with corresponding numbers, some had braille ones, some had neither. A template with braille numbers representing the candidates beside holes to mark your X could be used to hold a ballot, but there was nothing to hold the ballot in place – a potential for spoiling a ballot or voting for an unintended candidate. Many friends expressed concern over a lack of privacy, because an Elections Canada volunteer would have to place the ballot in the holder, then make sure the ballot didn’t slip. One friend of mine expressed shock that her ballot was taken from her and put in the ballot box on her behalf. Another was dismayed that she was grabbed and nearly dragged to the booth by an Elections Canada worker. Yet another had the misfortune of walking into the polling station and hearing (loudly) “Oh, here’s our first one!” and then having this same person direct all questions to her mother, who was there to cast her vote as well. Meagan even describes a completely bizarre requirement of having to write down the full name of the desired candidate – something that seemed unique to that polling station.
Voting is a right in this country. Perhaps because I chose not to vote, I have no right to describe or disparage the voting process. But the voters have spoken, and unfortunately, for many of the most misunderstood population, it was yet another way to be told that we aren’t quite equal, after all. I hope more steps can be taken in this country for equality for people with disabilities, whether it’s finding a job, raising a family, or voting in an election. But governments can only do so much; if attitudes don’t change, then I fear we’re just spitting into the wind.
as far as I know voting is often compulseary
LikeLike
Not in Canada. I have mixed feelings about mandatory voting, as I believe that an uninformed mandatory vote can be a dangerous prospect. That being said, it’s one thing not to vote because in your informed opinion there are grave concerns with all of the political parties, and not voting because you just don’t give a crap who runs your country/province/city.
LikeLike
think I was meant to have said more in my last comment blindbeader but something happened but anyway we try and beat the crouds to voting poling stations by voting early not because we might be out of town on the actual day but it’s for convenience purposes. if I had my way I’d say I don’t really care much for politics so won’t vote but if the voting here is mandatory it’s no excuse but I know I think the jahovas witnesses religion often are exempt from voting
LikeLike
As in most areas of life we find good and bad, those who understand and those who don’t. The situations you described are truly unforgivable and should be dealt with.
In my own situation, it was my first time back at the polls as a blind voter. I was assisted the moment I entered the door in a most courteous and unhurried manner.
They had obviously been well instructed on how to help. I was told to remove the ballot myself and no time would anyone handle it, even when I asked.
Just to let you know we are not all Cretans up here in Canada. With our new Prime Minister. pretty sure we are going to be brought back into a hopeful future in out country. Minister for the Disabled: is a low vision paraplegic former para olympian swimmer, with credentials the length of you arm, all involved with dealing with issues of disability. Many of us are very hopeful for the future in this country.
LikeLike
I am cautiously optimistic that things will go better up here in Canada, with this minister and many others who are in Cabinet.
I am simply pointing out that while some had positive voting experiences, others had VERY negative ones, and some had somewhere in between. Even leaving aside peoples’ attitudes and perceptions (which we are likely never to completely escape), there did not appear to be a particularly consistent process straight across the board for voter accessibility, and I believe Elections Canada should do something about this.
Thanks for reading, and writing in!
LikeLike
You are right in the fact that if you don’t expose the problems, they will not be dealt with. And truthfully I was amazed at the service I received.
As far as your cautious optimism, completely understand after the treatment the disabled have received, or mostly not received in this country. Have heard that our illustrious national organization for the blind, will undergo some serious changes. From volunteer and donation funded to a federally funded organization. There is faint hope.
LikeLike
In all aspects of life there is good and bad. There are people who shouldn’t be in a job and those who we are thankful for them being there for us.
It was my first time at voting as a blind voter. From the moment I walked in the door I was assisted thru the entire process without being hurried. No one would handle my ballot, but I was politely instructed with folding and depositing it in the box.
The situation in this country is lacking for people with disabilities, but hope is on the horizon. Our new Minister for Disabilities is a blind paraplegic. A former Para Olympic athlete in swimming. She has a long list of accomplishments dealing with human rights and needs for the disabled in professional capacity.
I hope that those who did not have a good experience this election day, can look forward to a better one next election.
LikeLike
Of course you have every right to speak up about this whether you vote or not, but I’m a huge fan of democracy and it just pains me when someone who has the right to vote chooses not to. Fodder for a different blog post, I suppose…
LikeLike
I completely respect that 🙂 That having been said, as I stated above, an uninformed vote or an obligatory one doesn’t serve democracy either, IMHO 🙂
LikeLike
Understood, and I agree that an obligatory vote (forcing people to vote) would not be democracy, but I worry about the idea that an “uninformed” vote doesn’t serve democracy. Who decides what qualifies a person as “informed”? I can imagine some judging people who are blind as “uninformed” because, for example, we can’t see the looks on the candidates faces when they give speeches?
_____
LikeLike
So, Dona Quixote, I see your sword didn’t stay hung up for long before you found another windmill worthy of your tilt.
While I am not involved in any way with Elections Canada (EC) I feel they really do make an effort to provide accessibility. A quick perusal of their website gives loads of information in regards to this.
Having a polling place where people need to use stairs is totally unacceptable and that sort of problem must be corrected, and EC provides an accessibility feedback form on their website.
Most of the other comments could be explained as “people being people”. Though there is training provided to the poll workers, we all know some people take to training like ducks to water while for others it’s more of a water off a duck’s back scenario.
I think that for something that comes up on a fairly irregular basis every four or so years EC does a pretty reasonable job. Fill out the feedback forms and maybe it will be smoother next we get to throw the bums out, or back in as the case may be.
LikeLike
Dad, funny thing… I didn’t think this was a swordfight as much as an open dialogue. Yes, people will be people, and that’s frustrating in many ways and heartening in many others. But I also think there needs to be some form of consistency for polling stations on Election Day as it relates to signage, voting templates, building accessibility, etc.
Certainly
LikeLike
Pingback: Breaking: Voting Blind is Still a Mess | Where's Your Dog?