Tags
autonomy, dignity, disability, employment, love, marriage, perception
One thing I’ve noticed over the years, particularly as it comes to interpersonal dynamics, is the idea that my life with a disability is so hard. I frequently encounter perceptions of strangers that I am unable to cook a meal, hold down a job, or raise a family, all because of my disability. Then there’s the confusion about what disability I actually DO live with every day. I, a blind woman, am perpetually told that I MUST need the elevator, rather than the flight of stairs to which I was asking directions. My friends who are deaf or hard of hearing have frequently told me of their experience of being spoken to in very. slow. and. measured. words – complete with sweeping arm and hand gestures – or having written conversations in what amounts to broken English because of the perception that they do not understand complete sentences. I’ve witnessed a friend in a wheelchair being spoken to like a small child, rather than the competent adult she is, simply because she is seated and therefore shorter than most adults.
Do you know what all this has in common? It’s someone else’s discomfort around disability… and not the challenge of disability itself. Most of us with disabilities have reached a place where the tools of disability are second-nature to us – how to navigate the world, prepare food for ourselves, take care of our bodies. We realize that many people haven’t gone through Disability 101 (a seemingly mandatory course in the school of Disability Acceptance that sometimes takes months, sometimes years to master), and we’re generally understanding of mistakes along the way. What doesn’t seem to make sense to us is the idea that a non-disabled person’s job is to make our life “easier” or “better.” Not only that, but the perception is that it’s up to the non-disabled person to decide what we require – a seat on the bus, a spot closer to the front of the lineup, an elevator instead of stairs – frequently putting us in situations where we have to firmly make our needs known because we were never asked in the first place. This then causes the “well-meaning” non-disabled person to call us ungrateful, rude, abrupt, or pushy for simply asserting our autonomy… because, after all, they “meant well.” We often are forced to have nerves of steel, to bottle up feelings of frustration and anger, not because our disability is so hard, but because it’s so exhausting being used as a “teachable moment“, or having to assert our desires and rights to work and play and access the same facilities that are so often taken for granted.
But you know what/ I’ve discovered? I can have nerves of steel, I can advocate perfectly for myself, I can say all the right things with a perfect tone… and I STILL am misunderstood. I hate that I have to write this, because admitting it means I need something from you. It actually IS your job to help make my life easier, and that of other disabled people in your sphere of influence. But you don’t get to pick and choose what would make our lives easier. In a beautifully eloquent post, my new friend Chris so eloquently wrote about the things that are easy – opening doors, giving us your place in line, offering your seat on the bus. In reference to the big things, the important things, the things that include us in society (work, education, opportunity) “… you’d gladly give me a seat on the bus, but how would you feel giving me a seat on the Board?”
What we want from you takes work on your part… and yet, it, too, is easy. It’s letting go of your perceptions and allowing us to be human beings, with the same hopes and dreams and desires and weaknesses that you have. Would you like to be the only person sitting in the living room during Christmas dinner preparations, twiddling your thumbs, offering to help and being told no, just sit there and look pretty? It happens to disabled family members all the time, and when we attempt to insert ourselves, it becomes an argument that ultimately makes everyone lose. Would you like to be told that you can’t get married to the love of your life? It happens to disabled couples all the time – either due to meddling family members or frustrating bureaucracy. Would you like to be told that your work experience is perfect but then get told that the company hired someone else, but that you’re so “inspirational” for showing up? I have lived this and witnessed this unprofessional attitude over and over again. How about stating a preference for certain activities and being told that it’s “so stereotypical” or too outlandish… for YOU, not for anyone else. Yep… lived that, too.
This is the big stuff, the stuff that makes life textured and complex. It’s frustrating that my own autonomy is so dependent on a non-disabled public listening and learning and letting go of their preconceptions. It’s frustrating that being treated with dignity and autonomy and respect, being provided with helpful information the first time we ask, being listened to when we politely self-advocate is the very rare exception to the rule. I’ve been offered more bus seats than I believe I’ve been thoughtfully considered for jobs for which I am qualified. I’ve been grabbed to direct me more often than I’ve been told that my husband and I are a cute couple just because we love each other, even as the ring on my finger is immediately obvious. I’ve been offered assistance and guidance for which I am extremely grateful, but I’ve also had it foisted on me. The little things do make our lives easier, and they do matter, and they matter a lot. But the big things – employment, education, love, autonomy, respect, consent – matter more, and those things truly do make our lives easier.
You’d gladly give me a seat on the bus, but how would you feel giving me a spot in your kitchen, an important position in your office, an evening babysitting your children, an opportunity where my skills and experience can stand on their own, a day at the altar… or a seat on the board?
I like so much about this post – I don’t know where to start! Thank you for writing this. The big things you mention are indeed what matter most.
LikeLike
Thank you so much! I’m glad you enjoyed it.
LikeLike
Both Laurette and I agree with you. If I had a say in it you would have a seat on the board. Maybe you should apply, I know they are going to expand the board soon.
LikeLiked by 1 person
What a well-written piece. Thanks for making the time and taking the effort to write it. Love your new friend’s “seat on the bus, seat on the board” quote.
_____
LikeLike
Yeah. It kinda prompted this post, which (as a friend stated) has been a long time in coming 🙂
LikeLike
Not sure you got my private message about reblogging this on the Easterseals National blog? If it’s okay for me to do that, can you email me privately to give me the go ahead?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Whereas I completely agree with your, Alysha, we older adults are in a relatively new game of accepted procedures and customs compared to those we were taught in our upbringing. For example: What constitutes accepted procedure today in regard to opening a door, or, giving your seat to someone simply because that someone happens to be a woman? Older woman? Woman with a child? Man with a child? a disabled person? …….or other situation calling for some sort of behavior?
I personally make a quick mental note of the situation, and respond accordingly without overtly identifying the recipiant of my actions.
Note: We folks generally act somewhat more helpful in a situation where additional assistance may/might be needed simply because we want to be helpful, and don’t really know how much help someone with a disability needs or wants…Please forgive us when we are mistaken.
When the ship is sinking, does the old standard, “women and children first” still apply?
I would suggest we’ve made some progress along the way, although far too little by some standards. In my 40 years of professional YMCA work, for example, I’ve had the wonderful experience of working with our first, female president of the board, and, also, the first Jewish president of the board, and, the first Morman chairman of the program committee, and the first Roman Catholic President of the board. Women, girls and minorities are not only accepted as full, fledged members of the YMCA during my tenure, but associations that didn’t respond accordingly are bared from membership in the National Council of YMCAs.
You may not know that in the beginning, the YMCA was a protestant, evangelical movement, strictly for young men……..so by that standard, the organization has taken several, giant leaps forward in 150 years.
We certainly wish and hope that other types of business and organizations would follow more rapidly. Some are, some are not and never will. Making money is their most important product…Sigh. Examples of the good, old boy system are observed quite often.
However, I urge you to keep an open mind, and watch for breakthroughs….For example, did you know that the Mission of the YWCA is twofold: “The Empowerment of Women,” and, “The Elimination of Racism”? Bet you never knew that.
Great article, by the way… Keep looking ahead—>
DON
LikeLike
Hi there!
I’m not sure to which Alysha you were referring, but I hope they read this discussion!
My own thoughts regarding progress, assistance, graciousness, go like this:
Someone can open a door or offer a seat on the bus or ask if we need help or directions. That is gracious and polite and simply being a decent human being, whether or not disability enters the equation. I would hope that such people would open doors for strangers, offer anyone a seat on a crowded bus, or ask anyone looking disoriented and confused if they need directions to a bus stop or a store.
It is also perfectly acceptable for offers of assistance to be graciously accepted or declined. THIS is where communication needs to be clear and concise. “No, thanks, I sit all day for a living,” or “I would rather explore my surroundings and find the stairs for myself, but thanks for the offer.” If that is done politely, it’s important to move on and accept the answer for what it is. What often gets people in trouble is that help is forced on us: “You want the stairs? here’s the elevator. Oh, but the stairs are dangerous for you… here’s the elevator. Are you SURE you can manage the stairs?”
I think it’s important for communication to go both ways and be an effective dialogue. Assistance is offered all the time to those without disabilities, and nobody thinks twice about them being turned down with a polite “no thank you.” So why is my “no thanks” discounted? Serious question.
But it also speaks to something deeper and bigger. People are quick to offer their assistance, and much slower at offering their offices or their classrooms. This obviously isn’t always the case, but it happens so often that the same person who will hold a door open for you is the same person who will, later in the week, turn you down for a job because – even if you’re qualified – you’ve got a disability and therefore are “other.”
LikeLike
Thank Uyou for writing this article. It really is frustrating, no matter how many times you bring this to the attention of the general public, they either don’t listen or think you are animosity filled, angry, and better and whatever they choose to call it. However, these people do not walk in our shoes. Non-disabled people do not put up with half of the things that we do. I apologize for any dictation errors, I said bitter. Anyway, it’s true they are quick to give up ACH or grab you without knowing if you even need assistance. However, some of them I’m sure do it out of kindness and don’t know what they are doing, I think other people do it out of pity. But that’s probably the same reason why we don’t get hired for a job even with the best qualifications. Seems like some people will only help when they feel sorry for us, not help or give us a chance when we have just as much knowledge or education as somebody who is able bodied applying for the same job.
LikeLike